?

Log in

Round 2 Evaluation

Now that the dust has settled from the second round of writerinatardis and Christmas is all done and dusted, I'd like to take the oppurtunity to get some feedback from both the authors and the voters on how you think it went.

I will be screening all comments to this post and am asking you to be honest in what you think went well in the round or what you think was done badly and how you think it might be better run.

What did you like?

What didn't you like?

What would you like to see?

What would you like to not see?

I'd also like some feedback on how you think I went as co-ordinator of the comm? I know there were a few times when I was late or things got mixed up but on the whole how did I do?

One thing I have noticed by reading posts about the comm is that some people don't like the feedback situation - they feel uncomfortable leaving feedback or have trouble articulating why they liked/didn't like as much a particular fic - Would people prefer to just have a vote basis with feedback being an option that people can leave but aren't forced to?


Also I'd like to gauge the interest in a 3rd Round? What are the levels of interest (is there any interest)? Would you participate? Vote?

Author Reveal and Open Post for 2.13

Here is the author reveal for 2.13

Feel free to ask the community for feedback and discuss anything here in the comments.

Author Story For Against Total
nipplemuggins We Break Like Glass 3 6 -3
the_tenzo Equilibrium 6 3 3


All writers - please leave a comment here if you would like your feedback emailed to you.

and the winner of Round 2 is........

Thank you to everyone for voting this week.

Congratulations to the_tenzo for winning the second round!!
You now have control of the TARDIS!! Please don't forget to land in Cardiff to refill her :)

Also congratulations to nipplemuggins. You were the last one to be put in the TARDIS :)

I'd like to thank all the fabulous writers for participating and I'd also like to take this oppurtunity to thank all the voters. It wouldn't have worked without any of you.

I've learnt a lot this round and I hope everyone enjoyed themselves. There will be a post up soon to see if there is enough interest for a third round and to discuss any changes that may happen with lessons learnt.

Banners will be provided shortly for both the winners and all the particpants as well. Please stay tuned.


and now on to the board:

Author 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
achuislemochroi                          
azriona    
                   
avoria                          
bad_wolf_42         X                
corusca     X                    
cotume27     X                    
dashafeather  
        X            
doctorsdiva  
                     
electrictoes          
             
emerald_soleil   X                      
gowdie          
             
heather916                 X        
jellybean728              
         
jessalrynn      
                 
ladychi            
     
   
linnea_1            
           
lostwolfchats
   
 
     
     
malana   X                      
misshapenmuse   X                      
nemesishamartia   X                      
nipplemuggins        
       
 
nylana  
           
       
risingfire   X                      
sonic_sparkle   X                      
spikewriter                
   
 
the_tenzo              
   
 
theyellow_daisy
X                      
whollyuncertain         X                
wildwinterwitch    
 
               


Story submitted
X Story not submitted
Winner of challenge
Voted into TARDIS


All fics are now available for you to display as you please.

I'll be posting who wrote what fics and the scores soon after this and then the next challenge very shortly!

Voting Post 2.13

This is it ladies and gentlemen! The post to decide who wins the second round of Writerinatardis! (that reminds me - must do banners).

The voting in the last couple of challenges have been very small. Please try to encourage as much voting as you can.

THIS *IS* THE PLACE TO POST YOUR VOTES.

EDITED FOR CLARIFICATION: Voting a fic into the TARDIS is voting to eliminate them from the competition.

Voting them as a winner is voting to keep them in the competition.



**PLEASE ENSURE THAT YOU ONLY VOTE FOR 1 WINNER AND 1 ELIMINATED. I DO NOT ACCEPT 'TIED' VOTES**

Any tied votes are automatically discarded AND NOT COUNTED TOWARDS THE RESULT.


Voting procedure for Round 2.13

#1. Read the story post before voting.

#2. This round we'll be placing ONE writer in the TARDIS. Please use the following format to ensure that votes are tabulated correctly:

Voted into the TARDIS
Story #:
Story Title:
Reason for vote:


#3. We will have one winner this round. Again, use the following format to vote:

Winner of Round 2.13
Story #:
Story Title:
Reason for vote:


Please put both votes in the one comment. It will be easier for me to tabulate if I don't have to chase them all. You must vote for both an entry into the TARDIS and a winner.

Also please leave constructive feedback for the writer.

Things to consider when leaving your feedback
I. The writer does actually get and read your feedback. Please consider the wording and tone of your comment.

II. Please note that any formatting you put in the LJ comment regarding feedback won't copy across. All I do is copy and paste the feedback into a database and none of the formatting copies across. If you are diligent to want formatting in your feedback could you please kindly use the html tags for it.

#4. You must vote for one TARDIS-occupant and one winner. Writers cannot vote for themselves for either category.

#5. Please encourage everyone to vote. Voters do not need to be members/watchers of the comm. Please do NOT indicate which story is yours when you do this.

#6. Do not discuss your votes until after the reveal. We want each voter's pure, uninfluenced opinions. Thanks.


Voting is open from now until 07:00pm EST Sunday December 20th, 2009. At that time no further votes will be counted, but it may take another hour or two for me to get the results up.

Stories 2.13 (1/1)

Stories are copied and posted exactly as submitted. No formatting changes, no editing, no clean-up beyond headers. Stories will not be edited for author-errors. However if you should notice a formatting problem, let me know so I can fix it. Remember to read BOTH stories before you vote.

Comments have been turned off as some people have voted or left feedback here which is the wrong thing to do.

Prompt: Ending


Title: 1. We Break Like Glass
Doctor: Ten
Warnings: None
Spoilers: None, except hints at Doomsday. Sort of takes the place of Fear Her.
Rating: Teen
1. We Break Like GlassCollapse )


Title: 2. Equilibrium
Doctor: Ten
Warnings: None
Spoilers: None
Rating: Teen
2. EquilibriumCollapse )

Challenge 2.13

This final prompt is courtesy of spikewriter.

This is it people, the final challenge for Round 2! Congratulations to nipplemuggins and the_tenzo for making it this far.

Prompt: Endings

Word Count: Up to 1500 words

Fics are to be emailed to writerinatardis [at] optusnet [dot] com [dot] au

Stories are due Wednesday, 16 December 2009, Midnight EST time.

Author Reveal and Open Post for 2.12

Here's the author reveal for 2.12

Feel free to ask the community for feedback and discuss anything here in the comments.

Author Story For Against Total
nipplemuggins The Time-Traveller's Lover 3 0 3
spikewriter Thoughts Along the Way 0 2 -2
the_tenzo The Wild Christmas Goose, and Chasings Thereof 0 1 -1


All writers - please leave a comment here if you would like your feedback emailed to you.

Results 2.12

It was yet another quiet week for votes with only 3 people voting.

The votes have been tallied and I'm afraid it's time to say goodbye to spikewriter.

Congratulation to nipplemuggins!

spikewriter - if you would like to suggest the next prompt could you leave it here for me otherwise I will suggest the next prompt.

and now on to the board:

Author 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
achuislemochroi                        
azriona    
                 
avoria                        
bad_wolf_42         X              
corusca     X                  
cotume27     X                  
dashafeather  
        X          
doctorsdiva  
                   
electrictoes          
           
emerald_soleil   X                    
gowdie          
           
heather916                 X      
jellybean728              
       
jessalrynn      
               
ladychi            
     
 
linnea_1            
         
lostwolfchats
   
 
     
   
malana   X                    
misshapenmuse   X                    
nemesishamartia   X                    
nipplemuggins        
       
 
nylana  
           
     
risingfire   X                    
sonic_sparkle   X                    
spikewriter                
   
the_tenzo              
   
 
theyellow_daisy
X                    
whollyuncertain         X              
wildwinterwitch    
 
             


Story submitted
X Story not submitted
Winner of challenge
Voted into TARDIS


All fics are now available for you to display as you please.

I'll be posting who wrote what fics and the scores soon after this and then the next challenge very shortly!

Voting Post 2.12

THIS *IS* THE PLACE TO POST YOUR VOTES.

EDITED FOR CLARIFICATION: Voting a fic into the TARDIS is voting to eliminate them from the competition.

Voting them as a winner is voting to keep them in the competition.



**PLEASE ENSURE THAT YOU ONLY VOTE FOR 1 WINNER AND 1 ELIMINATED. I DO NOT ACCEPT 'TIED' VOTES**

Any tied votes are automatically discarded AND NOT COUNTED TOWARDS THE RESULT.


Voting procedure for Round 2.12

#1. Read the story post before voting.

#2. This round we'll be placing ONE writer in the TARDIS. Please use the following format to ensure that votes are tabulated correctly:

Voted into the TARDIS
Story #:
Story Title:
Reason for vote:


#3. We will have one winner this round. Again, use the following format to vote:

Winner of Round 2.12
Story #:
Story Title:
Reason for vote:


Please put both votes in the one comment. It will be easier for me to tabulate if I don't have to chase them all. You must vote for both an entry into the TARDIS and a winner.

Also please leave constructive feedback for the writer.

Things to consider when leaving your feedback
I. The writer does actually get and read your feedback. Please consider the wording and tone of your comment.

II. Please note that any formatting you put in the LJ comment regarding feedback won't copy across. All I do is copy and paste the feedback into a database and none of the formatting copies across. If you are diligent to want formatting in your feedback could you please kindly use the html tags for it.

#4. You must vote for one TARDIS-occupant and one winner. Writers cannot vote for themselves for either category.

#5. Please encourage everyone to vote. Voters do not need to be members/watchers of the comm. Please do NOT indicate which story is yours when you do this.

#6. Do not discuss your votes until after the reveal. We want each voter's pure, uninfluenced opinions. Thanks.


Voting is open from now until 07:00pm EST Sunday December 6, 2009. At that time no further votes will be counted, but it may take another hour or two for me to get the results up.

Stories Post (1/1)

Stories are copied and posted exactly as submitted. No formatting changes, no editing, no clean-up beyond headers. Stories will not be edited for author-errors. However if you should notice a formatting problem, let me know so I can fix it. Remember to read BOTH story posts before you vote.

Comments have been turned off as some people have voted or left feedback here which is the wrong thing to do.

Prompt:

Before beginning a Hunt, it is wise to ask someone what you are looking for before you begin looking for it.
A. A. Milne


Title: 1. The Wild Christmas Goose, and Chasings Thereof
Doctor: Ten II
Warnings: None
Spoilers: None
Rating: All ages
1. The Wild Christmas Goose, and Chasings ThereofCollapse )


Title: 2. Thoughts Along the Way
Doctor: Nine, Ten, Ten II
Warnings: None
Spoilers: Through “Journey’s End”
Rating: PG-13
2. Thoughts Along the WayCollapse )


Title: 3. The Time-Traveller’s Lover
Doctor: Ten
Warnings: None
Spoilers: For Doomsday
Rating: Teen
3. The Time-Traveller’s LoverCollapse )